Jeremy H - October 10, 2023
An ESB (Enterprise Service Bus) allows you to integrate the disparate applications and services that run your organization. In this article, we take a closer look at what an ESB is and what alternatives exist. By connecting all these components through an ESB, you eliminate the labor-intensive task of custom-coding messy, point-to-point integrations. In this way, an ESB provides a safe, fast, and reliable backbone to your IT infrastructure.
However, it’s important to remember that an ESB is not the only app integration solution. There are certain circumstances where an iPaaS (Integration Platform as a Service) can serve as a less expensive, easier-to-use ESB alternative.
In this guide, we’ll help you understand what ESB technology is, when you should use it, and when you should consider an iPaaS solution instead. We’ll also review the three most popular ESB/iPaaS solutions on the market today.
Here’s the key things to know about ESB and its alternatives:
- ESBs serve as stable communication buses between applications, replacing messy point-to-point integrations.
- They utilize pre-built software adapters for pluggable app integration, enabling new integrations, upgrades, and growth.
- ESB components include messaging servers, canonical messaging formats, software adapters, and stateless servers.
- Notable ESB and iPaaS tools include DreamFactory (iPaaS), MuleSoft Anypoint Platform (ESB/iPaaS), and IBM App Connect (hybrid ESB/iPaaS).
- Considerations for choosing between ESB and iPaaS include integration complexity, costs, ease of use, scalability, security, customization, real-life examples, and hybrid approaches.
Table of Contents
How an ESB Works
Before ESBs, businesses used to struggle with custom-coded, point-to-point application integrations. These point-to-point integrations resulted in messy “spaghetti code” and too-difficult-to-untangle application dependencies. Today, an ESB eliminates these challenges by serving as a stable communications bus between applications.
The ESB achieves this through a host of pre-built software adapters, which create a “pluggable” app integration solution — one that facilitates new application integrations, system upgrades, and business growth. Another benefit of ESBs is their speed, which is fast enough to support real-time data integrations.
A typical ESB features the following components and characteristics:
- Messaging server: As a communication bus between applications, an ESB prevents applications from having direct contact with each other via a messaging broker (usually AMQP or JMS). The messaging broker creates a standard that the ESB uses to send and receive messages within itself.
- Canonical messaging format: Messages passing through the ESB are in a canonical (consistent) format — usually XML. This provides consistency while requests route through the bus. Some ESBs permit additional messaging formats — like JSON, flat files, binary, Java objects, and more.
- Software adapters: The ESB uses software adapters to transform application messages into the ESB’s canonical messaging format (usually XML). Before delivery, the ESB transforms the messages a second time into the receiving application’s protocol. ESBs include an array of pre-built adapters for the most popular platforms, protocols, and legacy applications. Adapters can also perform security monitoring, error management, message routing, and transaction management.
- Stateless server: ESBs are usually stateless. A stateless server doesn’t use or maintain information from previous requests. Instead, it maintains the state within the messages as they route through the ESB. This means that ESBs process messages based only on the information provided in the message itself.
When to Use an ESB
Here are the most important use cases for an ESB:
- Integrating more than two services or applications: When integrating more than two services or applications, an ESB streamlines the building of application integrations, providing reliable, secure and often instant connections — while also preventing application entanglement/dependency.
- Integrating an external service platform: When integrating an external service platform, an ESB provides a reliable connection while managing and controlling service level commitments to minimize the impact of adjustments to your service agreements.
- Transforming and integrating multiple communication protocols: ESBs are especially good at transforming multiple protocols into one — such as transforming FTP and HTTP into SOAP or weaving together SMTP, IIOP, MQ/JMS. They can also handle many different data formats.
- Frequently adding new applications or services: When you’re constantly adding, changing, or upgrading applications and services, the “pluggability” of an ESB’s pre-built adapters will facilitate these changes.
- Integrating legacy applications: ESBs also include a variety of pre-built adapters to integrate legacy applications with modern apps and services.
- When connection security and reliability are needed: An ESB offers a simple, secure way to connect and transform transactional messages as they pass between two dissimilar data sources.
- Dealing with industry-specific protocols: When you need to integrate industry-specific protocols with other systems, your ESB should include the pre-built adapters your industry protocol requires. For example, an ESB can transform and integrate the healthcare industry protocol HL7 with your other applications.
When Not to Use an ESB
Here are the use cases when you shouldn’t use an ESB:
- Integrating large volumes of data: If you need to send large volumes of data — perhaps while extracting and loading data from one database or data warehouse to another — your ESB will not replace an ETL tool. ESBs are designed to integrate applications and platforms, which don’t require massive data transfers. An ETL platform is more appropriate for large-volume data integrations.
- Implementing stateful business processes: If you need to implement long-running, stateful, business processes, an ESB is probably not appropriate. You’ll want to use a BPMS (Business Process Management System) that offers implementation through either BPMN (Business Process Model and Notation) or BPEL (Business Process Execution Language).
- Integrating cloud-based applications: If you’re integrating cloud-based applications, web applications, web dashboards, mobile applications, a network of IoT apps, or SaaS applications, you should consider an iPaaS instead of an ESB.
iPaaS Technology: An ESB Alternative
An iPaaS (Integration Platform-as-a-Service) is an app integration solution that can complement or replace an ESB when integrating cloud-based platforms, web applications, mobile apps, IoT devices, and more. When an iPaaS is appropriate for your use case, you’ll benefit from the following advantages:
- Speed, ease-of-use, and cost-effectiveness: An iPaaS will get you up and running faster, without the learning curve, staffing requirements, or large financial investments associated with an ESB.
- Automatically generate REST API: The most advanced iPaaS solutions — like DreamFactory iPaaS — can instantly generate REST APIs without the need for time-consuming coding (something ESB solutions can’t do without extensive coding).
- Better security and compliance: iPaaS solutions offer more advanced security and governance technology than ESBs.
Here are the main use cases for iPaaS:
- Software-as-a-service integrations: A “cloud ESB” will integrate your cloud-based SaaS platforms with a complex messaging protocol like MOM (message-oriented middleware). However, iPaaS performs the same integrations with a lighter-weight messaging standard like JSON, REST, and API, making iPaaS integrations convenient, secure, and easier to set up.
- Software multitenancy integrations: Software multitenancy — or a multi-tenant architecture — is when a single software instance operates on one server while servicing multiple departments. While an ESB will struggle to manage the complexity of multi-tenant architecture, an iPaaS can lower integration redundancy while reducing your hardware and software requirements.
- Ad hoc application integrations: Ad hoc applications are usually cloud-based, SaaS applications and easy to set up without IT involvement. However, you’ll still need to integrate them. Setting up an ESB connection requires extensive technical expertise, but anyone can use an iPaaS to integrate ad hoc SaaS applications in minutes.
- Internet-of-Things (IoT) mobile app integrations: The features of iPaaS — such as llighter-weightmessaging standards (JSON, REST, and API), low latency, real-time connections, and support for external integrations — provide the horizontal scalability needed for connecting a network of IoT applications and devices. In most cases, ESB is too slow and heavy to service these demands.
3 Popular ESB and iPaaS Tools
DreamFactory (iPaaS)
DreamFactory is an open-source iPaaS solution — that runs on-premises or in the cloud. The platform was created to solve a very specific problem: How do you expose data from your web and cloud-based applications and data sources in the easiest, fastest, and most secure way possible? In achieving this goal, DreamFactory can automatically generate REST APIs to expose your data in just three minutes. Best of all, you don’t need any special training or technical experience to use it.
Noteworthy features of DreamFactory include:
- Runs anywhere, on-premises or in the cloud
- Instant API creation
- Automatic SOAP to REST conversion
- Data mesh to combine unrelated databases
- Server-side scripting
- Deep SQL support
- Live API docs
- API publishing
In terms of data security and compliance, DreamFactory offers:
- Numerous tools to satisfy corporate and regulatory compliance standards like GDPR, HIPAA, CCPA, etc.
- A suite of data access controls, like role-based access control (RBAC)
- Flexible support for popular enterprise authentication solutions
- API logs sent to your logging solution of choice
Although DreamFactory is free and open-source, it includes three paid tiers (Basic, Professional, and Enterprise), which offer 24-hour tech support and additional pre-built connectors. DreamFactory’s most popular out-of-the-box connectors include:
- Cassandra
- IBM Db2
- Microsoft SQL Server
- MongoDB
- MySQL
- Oracle
- PostgreSQL
- Redis
- SQLite
Finally, DreamFactory offers custom contracts to ensure you only pay for the features you need. As a result, DreamFactory costs magnitudes less than the MuleSoft and IBM ESB solutions highlighted below.
MuleSoft Anypoint Platform (ESB/iPaaS)
MuleSoft’s Anypoint Platform is a hybrid ESB/iPaaS solution for connecting and integrating your network of on-premises or cloud-based apps, data, and IoT devices. This platform gives developers the opportunity to rapidly add new applications. They can do this with any type of application, even if it uses a different type of technology. It’s possible to unite everything from JDBC, JMS, Web Services, HTTP, and others.
Although MuleSoft is a feature-rich platform, it comes with a steep learning curve. Any developer interested in using it will require extensive training and coding experience — something that isn’t required with an iPaaS solution like DreamFactory, which allows you to instantly generate REST APIs through a no-code interface.
Finally, MuleSoft is expensive, costing hundreds of thousands of dollars a year (and sometimes millions) to operate. In some situations, these costs may be worth it if you need to support older messaging standards, legacy on-premises systems, cloud-based applications, or integrate a complex enterprise IT infrastructure.
IBM App Connect
IBM App Connect is another option when it comes to a hybrid ESB/iPaaS. The platform is somewhat similar to the MuleSoft Anypoint Platform. As a hybrid integration platform, IBM App Connect offers instant connections for applications, data, legacy systems, cloud-based platforms, and IoT devices. While it lets users create REST APIs, the process requires extensive manual coding. Developers will need to have a thorough understanding of the platform in order to use it. Finally, IBM App Connect features a variety of integration styles, like real-time, event-based, and scheduled batch data copy/synchronization. It also offers pre-created application connectors.
Like the MuleSoft Anypoint Platform, IBM App Connect represents a considerable financial and training investment before you can take advantage of its wide range of capabilities. If needed, the capabilities of this platform more than pay for themselves, but when they’re not necessary, consider whether a less expensive iPaaS platform can meet your app integration needs.
Key Considerations When Choosing Between ESB and iPaaS
When it comes to deciding between an ESB (Enterprise Service Bus) and an iPaaS (Integration Platform-as-a-Service), a few important factors come into play. Here’s a straightforward look at what you need to consider:
- Integration Complexity: Think about how many different applications, data sources, and communication protocols you’re dealing with. If things are pretty straightforward, an iPaaS might be all you need. But if it’s getting complex, an ESB might offer more control.
- Costs: Money matters. ESBs can involve higher upfront costs, including hardware and licensing. iPaaS tends to be more budget-friendly, but be sure to consider the ongoing expenses for both options.
- Ease of Use: How tech-savvy is your team? ESBs can require more technical expertise, while iPaaS solutions are often designed to be user-friendly.
- Scalability: If you’re planning to grow fast or have increasing integration needs, think about which solution can scale with your business.
- Security and Compliance: Depending on your industry, security and compliance requirements might be a big deal. Check which solution offers the security features and compliance options you need.
- Customization: Consider how much you want to tailor your integrations. Some solutions are more flexible than others in this regard.
- Real-Life Examples: Look for real-world examples or case studies that match your situation. They can give you insights into what has worked for others.
- Hybrid Approach: Sometimes, a mix of ESB and iPaaS elements can be the right fit. Explore if a hybrid approach could meet your unique needs.
Choosing between ESB and iPaaS isn’t one-size-fits-all. It depends on your specific situation and goals. So, take a moment to weigh these factors before making your decision.
Conclusion
ESBs — such as MuleSoft Anypoint and IBM App Connect — can provide stable application integrations while serving as a “pluggable” backbone to your IT infrastructure. Nevertheless, if you’re integrating cloud-based applications, mobile apps, IoT devices, or web dashboards, iPaaS technology could offer an easier and less expensive solution. Also, the fact that an advanced iPaaS like DreamFactory can instantly generate REST APIs without any coding at all is a distinct advantage.
Ultimately, from the perspectives of cost, time-to-market, ease of use, and required skill level, DreamFactory presents a compelling ESB alternative that could serve many of your application integration needs.
Certainly! Here’s an FAQ section for the article:
Frequently Asked Questions: ESB and its Alternatives
What is an ESB, and how does it work?
An ESB, or Enterprise Service Bus, is a software architecture that facilitates communication and integration between different applications within an organization. It works by acting as a central messaging system, allowing various applications to communicate, share data, and execute processes in a standardized way.
What are the key components of an ESB?
The main components of an ESB typically include a messaging server, canonical messaging format, software adapters, and a stateless server. These components work together to ensure seamless communication and data exchange between applications.
When should I use an ESB?
You should consider using an ESB when integrating more than two services or applications, integrating an external service platform, transforming and integrating multiple communication protocols, frequently adding new applications or services, integrating legacy applications, or when you need secure and reliable connections between different data sources.
When should I not use an ESB?
An ESB may not be suitable for integrating large volumes of data, implementing stateful business processes, or integrating cloud-based applications, web applications, or SaaS applications. In such cases, an iPaaS (Integration Platform-as-a-Service) might be a better alternative.
What is iPaaS, and how does it differ from an ESB?
iPaaS, or Integration Platform-as-a-Service, is an alternative to ESB that specializes in integrating cloud-based platforms, web applications, mobile apps, and IoT devices. It offers advantages in terms of speed, ease of use, cost-effectiveness, and supports modern messaging standards like JSON and REST.
What are some popular ESB and iPaaS tools?
Popular ESB tools include MuleSoft Anypoint Platform and IBM App Connect. For iPaaS solutions, DreamFactory is a notable choice, offering features like instant API generation and enhanced security.
How do I choose between an ESB and iPaaS for my organization?
When choosing between ESB and iPaaS, consider factors such as integration complexity, costs, ease of use, scalability, security, compliance, customization needs, and real-life examples in your industry. In some cases, a hybrid approach combining both ESB and iPaaS elements may be the best fit.
What are the key considerations when deciding between ESB and iPaaS?
Key considerations include the complexity of your integration needs, budget constraints, the technical expertise of your team, scalability requirements, security and compliance considerations, the level of customization required, and whether a hybrid approach is suitable.
Related Reading
Fascinated by emerging technologies, Jeremy Hillpot uses his backgrounds in legal writing and technology to provide a unique perspective on a vast array of topics including enterprise technology, SQL, data science, SaaS applications, investment fraud, and the law. Contact Jeremy at [email protected].